Interjecting economics into the groundwater policy dialogue
Vol. 8 No. 1 (2017). Cover photo: Jacob’s Well, in Hays County, Texas. ©2015 Andy Heatwole.


groundwater bank accounts
optimal intertemporal use

How to Cite

“Interjecting Economics into the Groundwater Policy Dialogue”. 2017. Texas Water Journal 8 (1): 97-112.


Historically, economic theory has played a miniscule role in groundwater policy deliberations because of its complexity. This paper is intended for practitioners. Its goal is to distill the seminal 1931 paper by Harold Hotelling and show how it can be applied to manage a quasi-nonrenewable resource like groundwater. Hotelling’s framework is then used to critique both the rule of capture era and the current era of regulation by groundwater conservation districts. The latter also draws heavily on the analysis by Brady et al. in a 2016 Bush School Capstone Report. Finally, a regulatory fix is proposed based on the ideas of Nobel Laureate, Vernon Smith (1977) that would use groundwater bank accounts to assure the efficient use of groundwater over time.

Citation: Griffin JM. 2017. Interjecting economics into the groundwater policy dialogue. Texas Water Journal. 8(1):97-112. Available from:



Beal B. 2015. Williams permit denial upheld. The Fort Stock¬ton Pioneer. williams-permit-denial-upheld,2770?

Beckermann W, Brady R, Capps A, Kennedy B, McGee P, Northcut K, Parish M, Qadeer A, Shan S, Griffin JM. 2016. An assessment of groundwater regulation in Texas. Austin (Texas): Capstone report to Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts Glenn Hegar.

Brady R, Beckermann W, Capps A, Kennedy B, McGee P, Northcut K, Parish M, Qadeer A, Shan S, Griffin JM. 2016. Reorganizing groundwater regulation in Texas. Aus¬tin (Texas): Capstone report to Texas Comptroller of Pub¬lic Accounts Glenn Hegar.

Clark JA, Halbouty MT. 1972. The last boom. New York (New York): Random House.

Collins G, Blumberg H. 2016. Implementing three dimension¬al groundwater management in a Texas groundwater con¬servation district. Texas Water Journal. 7(1):69-81.

Cruse D. 2012. Landmark Texas water rights case may lead to future takings claims or legislative fixes: Edwards Aquifer v. Day. The Supreme Court of Texas Blog. http://www.scotx¬

Devlin JF, Sophocleous M. 2005. The persistence of the water budget myth and its relationship to sustainability. Hydro¬geology Journal. 13(4):549-554.

[EPA] United States Environmental Protection Agency. 2008. Indoor water use in the United States. EPA-832-F096-994. indoor508.pdf.

Goodwin S, Carlson K, Douglas C, Knox K. 2012. Life cycle analysis of water use and intensity of oil and gas recovery in Wattenberg field, Colo. Oil & Gas Journal. 110(5).

Griffin JM, Steele HB. 1986. Energy economics and policy. Orlando (Florida): Academic Press.

Griffin RC. 2006. Water resource economics: the analysis of scarcity, policies, and projects. Cambridge (Massachu¬setts): M.I.T. Press.

Harden B. 2016a. Testimony before Senate Committee on Agriculture, Water & Rural Affairs, Interim Report to the 85th Legislature, November 2016. Austin (Texas): Texas State Senate.

Harden B. 2016b. Testimony before Senate Committee on Agriculture, Water & Rural Affairs, July 25, 2016. Austin (Texas): Texas State Senate.

Hotelling H.1931. The economics of exhaustible resources. Journal of Political Economy. 39(2):137-175.

Johnson R. 2016. Testimony before the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Water & Rural Affairs, Interim Report to the 85th Legislature, November 2016. Austin (Texas): Texas State Senate.

Lashmet TD, Miller A. 2015. Texas exempt wells: where does fracking fit? Natural Resources Journal. 55(2):239-268.

Lesikar B, Kaiser R, Silvy V. 2002. Questions about groundwa¬ter conservation districts in Texas. College Station (Texas): Texas Cooperative Extension Service.

Mace RE, Petrosian R, Bradley R, Mullican WF 3rd, Christian L (Texas Water Development Board). 2008. A streetcar named desired future conditions: the new groundwater availability for Texas. Presented at The Changing Face of Water Rights in Texas; 2008 May 8-9, Bastrop, Texas. State Bar of Texas.

Mace RE, Ridgeway C, Sharp JM Jr. 2004. Groundwater is no longer secret and occult—A historical and hydrogeologic analysis of the East case. In: Mullican WF 3rd, Schwartz S, editors. 100 years of rule of capture: from East to ground¬water management. Austin (Texas): Texas Water Develop¬ment Board. Report No.: 361.

McCarthy ER. 2013. Motion for Rehearing in support of Forestar (USA) Real Estate Group, Inc.’s applications for drilling permits, operating permits and transfer permits for well nos. 1-10. Forestar_s-Motion-for-Rehearing-8-6-13-1.pdf.

[RRC] Railroad Commission of Texas. 2001. Waste minimi¬zation in the oil field; Chapter 5, Waste minimization and management in oil and gas operations.

[RRC] Railroad Commission of Texas. History of the Rail¬road Commission 1866-1939. about-us/history/history-1866-1939/.

Scheierling SM, Loomis JB. 2006. Irrigation water demand: a meta-analysis of price elasticities. Water Resources Research. 42(1):1-9.

Smith V. 1977. Water deeds: a proposed solution to the water valuation problem. Arizona Review, 26(1).

Steadman M, Arnett B, Healy K, Jiang Z, LeClere D, McLaugh¬lin L, Roberts J. 2015. Groundwater use in the Eagle Ford Shale: some policy recommendations. Texas Water Jour¬nal. 6(1):67-78. twj/article/view/7023.

[TWDB] Texas Water Development Board. 2001. Legislative Wrap Up: 77th Legislative Session.

Walters SJK. 1993. Enterprise, government, and the public. New York (New York): McGraw Hill. pp. 336-367.

Wiggins SN, Libecap GD. 1985. Oil field unitization: contrac¬tual failure in the presence of imperfect information. The American Economic Review. 75(3):368-385.

Wythe K. 2014. Texas groundwater administration: intersection of management and planning presents challeng¬es. txH2O: A publication of the Texas Water Resources Institute. 9(1):19-20. txh2o/summer-2014/texas-groundwater-administration/.

Zhou Y. 2009. A critical review of groundwater budget myth, safe yield and sustainability. Journal of Hydrology. 370(1):207-213.

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2017 James Milton Griffin